httpclient: 记录 RFC 9110 redirect gap, deferred test 锁住当前行为

代码 review 发现 DoWithRedirect 有两个 RFC 9110 §15.4 标准违反,
但当前不修:

  1. 303 See Other 应该把 method 切到 GET, 当前保持原 method (例如
     POST → 307 → 继续 POST). YARN/SHS 当前不用 303, gap 未触发.
  2. 307 Temporary Redirect / 308 Permanent Redirect 收到 POST 时
     应该原 method + body 重发, 当前 body 强制置 nil. YARN amContainerLogs
     是 GET 触发 307, gap 未触发.

不修原因: 没有真实用户报告. 修 307 body 重发要 buffer 起来 + 重写
Content-Length, 容易出 subtle bug (multipart/trailer). 修复成本 vs
收益不成比例.

新增 TestDoWithRedirect_DeferredRFC9110Gaps (2 subtest) 锁定当前
行为, 未来要修必须主动改测试 → 强制 review 行为变更. 同时给
redirect.go 加 TODO(redirect) 注释详细说明两个 gap 和修法方向.

subtest 修正一个错位: 303 的 body 丢失不是 gap (RFC 规定 303 必须
丢 body, 跟 method 错没错无关), gap 只是 method 保留 vs 切 GET.
已对应调整注释和断言.

未提交: .env (gitignored 内容之外有意未提交)

Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
tao.chen
2026-07-13 16:24:40 +08:00
co-authored by Claude
parent 1a7c692e79
commit 3bc8bd49f6
2 changed files with 93 additions and 0 deletions
+9
View File
@@ -56,6 +56,15 @@ func (c *Client) DoWithRedirect(ctx context.Context, req *http.Request, maxRedir
}
// **保留** header (Authorization 等)
newReq.Header = current.Header.Clone()
// TODO(redirect): per RFC 9110 §15.4, 303 See Other must switch the
// method to GET and drop the body; 307 Temporary Redirect and
// 308 Permanent Redirect must preserve both method AND body. This
// implementation always preserves the method and discards the body,
// which is correct for 307/308 GET (YARN amContainerLogs) but
// non-compliant for 303 and any 307/308 POST. Current YARN / SHS
// API surface only triggers 307 on GET, so the gap is unfired.
// TestDoWithRedirect_DeferredRFC9110Gaps locks the current behavior
// so a future fix must update that test deliberately.
newReq.Body = nil
current = newReq
}